Chong nguoi thi hanh cong vu Nen cho phep ban

Thứ sáu, 15 Tháng ba 2013, 07:31 GMT+7

– Nguoi thi hanh cong vu mang sung nhung khong duoc ban hay co ban thi lai la dan cao su, lam the thi toi pham hay con do cang khong biet so.

» No sung ban ke chong doi: Dung dan gi, ban vao dau?
» Cong an ban ke chong doi: Chuyen gia phap luat noi gi?
» De xuat cho ban nguoi chong can bo thi hanh cong vu


Du thao nghi dinh quy dinh cac bien phap phong ngua, ngan chan va xu ly hanh vi chong nguoi thi hanh cong vu cua Bo Cong an de xuat truong hop co dau hieu cua toi pham nghiem trong, rat nghiem trong, dac biet nghiem trong thi nguoi thi hanh cong vu duoc su dung cong cu ho tro, phuong tien ky thuat hoac no sung truc tiep vao nguoi va phuong tien vi pham de phong ve, tan cong, vo hieu hoa hanh vi chong nguoi thi hanh cong vu, kip thoi ngan chan hau qua xay ra va bat giu nguoi co hanh vi chong nguoi thi hanh cong vu.

Gui y kien den TS ve de xuat cho ban nguoi can bo thi hanh cong vu, nhieu doc gia to quan diem ung ho. Ban doc Vu Long noi “toi thay dua ra nghi dinh nay la dung va can nhanh chong hoan thien”.

Theo ban Vu Long, hien nay tinh hinh xa hoi da khac truoc, suy thoai kinh te va su anh huong tu ben ngoai nen te nan ngay cang nhieu. Phai cho phep nguoi thi hanh cong vu duoc phep ban toi pham chong doi.

“Toi thay nguoi thi hanh cong vu mang sung nhung khong duoc ban hay co ban thi lai la dan cao su. Lam the thi toi pham hay con do cang khong biet so? Toi thay cho phep cong an dung ca dan that luon (duong nhien la kem voi dan cao su de tran ap nguoi qua khich), luc do nhung ke con do hay toi pham moi biet so” – Doc gia Vu Long phan tich.

Chong nguoi thi hanh cong vu: Nen cho phep ban
Nhieu ban doc to quan diem dong tinh voi de xuat cho phep no sung, ban nguoi chong can bo thi hanh cong vu.
Tuy nhien, ban Long cung cho rang, trong truong hop, nguoi vi pham chi chong doi thong thuong, chua co bieu hien nguy hiem thi co the ban bi thuong hoac dung vu luc de tuoc hung khi cua doi tuong, “lam vay moi lay lai duoc uy nghiem cua nganh cong an tran ap toi pham”.

"Vi ly do nay, nghi dinh can neu ro khi nao moi duoc rut sung ra ban chet hoac ban bi thuong va ben canh do mot nghi dinh di kem ve viec quan ly vu khi quan dung chat che hon nua", Vu Long gop y.

Bay to quan diem ung ho de xuat cho phep no sung doi voi nguoi chong can bo thi hanh cong vu, doc gia Tran Thiet Giao bay to “Chinh vi bi han che quyen su dung sung cua luc luong thi hanh cong vu nen bon toi pham moi long hanh nhu hien nay”.

Doc gia Nguyen Mao cung cho rang: “Trong tinh hinh hien nay, rat nhieu ke chong nguoi thi hanh cong vu gay lo lang cho xa hoi. Do vay viec ban hanh nghi dinh la can thiet khong can ban cai qua nhieu gay cham tre”.

Theo ban doc PhuongSang: “Cai nay dang le phai lam tu lau nhu o nuoc ngoai, dung sung cao su va sung dien thoi. Canh sat cung phai co "suc manh" khi thi hanh cong vu chu, nhat la doi voi nhung ke bat tri”.

Trong khi do, doc gia Ha Chin neu y van de “tai sao chung ta khi ban bac ve mot van de lon lai khong chiu hi sinh mot loi ich rat nho. Thuc trang chong nguoi thi hanh cong vu ngay cang nhieu… do la bieu hien cua viec "nhon luat" hoac co o du che lap va lach luat”.

Doc gia Chin cho rang, mot phan khong nho nhung ke chong nguoi thi hanh cong vu deu la "con ong, chau cha" nen khi nha nuoc chuan bi ra nghi dinh cho phep no sung truc tiep vao nguoi thi hanh cong vu thi lai keu "so lam quyen".

Chong nguoi thi hanh cong vu: Nen cho phep ban
Mot can bo kiem lam bi lam tac hanh hung, gay thuong tich nam 2012.
Anh: Phap luat TP.HCM

“Bat cu dieu gi cung khong the toan ven duoc. Cho phep no sung vao ke chong nguoi thi hanh cong vu dam bao 99,9% tinh trang chong nguoi thi hanh cong vu se cham dut (tru nhung ke khong so chet). Tat nhien khi ban hanh nghi dinh tren se dan den viec lam quyen: ban bua bai. Khi do chi la 1 phan nho ma thoi. Voi lai ai sai thi xu li nguoi do” – Ban Ha Chin khang dinh.

Ban ve viec chong lam quyen khi ban, ban doc Minh Do cho rang, khi thi hanh cong vu nen di it nhat la 2 nguoi va mang theo cac thiet bi ghi hinh de chung minh hanh dong cua canh sat la dung, phu hop. "Vi du nhu truong hop nguoi thanh nien cam chai thuy tinh tan cong thi co the ban vao tay hoac vao chan la phu hop” – Ban Minh Do phan tich.

Ben canh nhung y kien dong tinh, nhieu ban doc to ra lo lang vi nhung dieu trong du thao con “tu mu” va lo ngai nguoi duoc giao sung lam quyen.

“The nao la hanh dong hay ngon ngu chong doi ? Muc do chong doi de canh sat co quyen ban ? Chong doi o muc do co hay khong co vu khi ? vu khi chong doi loai gi thi cong an duoc phep ban. Tat ca deu tu mu. Quyet dinh nay chac chan se la giam tinh kiem che truoc phap luat cua cong an” – Doc gia Hoang Anh lo lang.

Cung quan diem nay, ban Le Quang Danh ban khoan ve dinh nghi ro rang the nao la chong nguoi thi hanh cong vu, vi neu khong ro rang thi cau noi nay rat me ho.

Tu do, ban Danh dat gia thiet, giua nguoi thi hanh cong va 1 cong dan chi xay ra loi qua tieng lai, ma trong khi 1 cong dan chua hieu luat phat ro rang thi nguoi thi hanh cong vu co duoc ban ho khong?


“Moi vien dan con gan voi luong tam”

Tra loi phong van tren bao Tien phong ngay 13/3, Thieu tuong Tran Van Ve (Pho Tong cuc truong Tong cuc Canh sat Quan ly hanh chinh ve trat tu an toan xa hoi, Bo Cong an cho biet, viec Bo Cong an xay dung du thao Nghi dinh tren nham tao hanh lang phap ly cho can bo chien sy lam nhiem vu doc lap tu bao ve tinh mang cua minh, nguoi khac va tai san quoc gia.

Theo Thieu tuong Ve, thuc te co can bo no sung vuot qua gioi han phong ve chinh dang hoac nosung vao truong hop khong phai toi pham, song theo toi day chi la nhung truong hop hy huu.

Khi quyet dinh no sung vao toi pham con phai can nhac nhieu dieu, ngoai quy dinh con la luong tam con nguoi voi nhau… Neu nguoi thi hanh cong vu co tinh vi pham thi du co quy dinh chat che den may cung van xay ra viec lam quyen. Toi nghi du thao Nghi dinh se duoc quy dinh chat che, dam bao khong trai Phap lenh cung nhu khong de ke ho dan den viec lam quyen.

Thieu tuong Tran Van Ve khang dinh rang, bat ke la luc luong nao cung phai tuan thu cac quy dinh cua phap luat, neu truong hop doi tuong tan cong khong gay nguy hiem cho tinh mang CBCS hoac nguoi khac thi khong duoc ban.

» No sung ban ke chong doi: Dung dan gi, ban vao dau?
» Cong an ban ke chong doi: Chuyen gia phap luat noi gi?
» De xuat cho ban nguoi chong can bo thi hanh cong vu


Thuy Tran
(tong hop)

Cac bai viet khac:

Tiep theo >>


^ Lên đầu trang ^


Copyright © 2006-2012 by VietBao.vn
Viet Bao Viet Nam - All Rights Reserved.