Vu kien an cap ca khuc Dam Vinh Hung pham nhieu toi

Chủ nhật, 30 Tháng sáu 2013, 08:28 GMT+7

Theo luat su, nhac sy Truong Nhan kien Dam Vinh Hung la dung, Dam Vinh Hung cung co the khoi kien rieng nguoi ban ca khuc cho anh sau khi da ket thuc vu an voi tac gia ca khuc Chut tinh.

--------------------------------

Co the ban quan tam

>> Chet lang vi Dam Vinh Hung

>> Dam Vinh Hung tiet lo 10 cai "dau tien" trong doi

>> Dam Vinh Hung da chuoc duoc dong ho nam kim cuong

----------------------------------

Nhu TS da dua tin, nhac sy tre Nguyen Truong Nhan da khoi kien ca sy Dam Vinh Hung len toan an va cong bo tren bao chi su viec ca khuc cua anh bi danh cap, su dung trai phep.

Cu the la ca khuc Chut tinh cua Truong Nhan da duoc dang ky tac quyen nam 2006 nhung thang 7/2012, Dam Vinh Hung da phat hanh album Goc khuat, trong do co ca khuc Chut tinh phai (cung chinh la ca khuc Chut tinh) voi phan tac gia duoc gioi thieu la Truong Tuan Huy.


Nguyen Truong Nhan
Don kien Dam Vinh Hung cua nhac sy tre Truong Nhan
Can cu vao nhung thong tin ca 2 phia la nhac sy Truong Nhan va phia ca sy Dam Vinh Hung cung cap tren bao den nay, luat su Nguyen Thanh Cong (thuoc Doan Luat su TP.HCM) cho biet:

"Can cu nhung thong tin tren bao, nhac sy Truong Nhan kien Dam Vinh Hung la dung. Tuy nhien phai xac dinh vu viec nay co 2 quan he tu 2 nhom doi tuong khac nhau, co the hinh thanh nen 2 vu an rieng biet nhung cung co the giai quyet ngay trong 1 vu an.


luat su Nguyen Thanh Cong_Dam Vinh Hung bi kien an cap ca khuc
Luat su Nguyen Thanh Cong (Doan Luat su TP.HCM)
San pham Album Goc khuat cua Dam Vinh Hung la hoan toan hop phap. Gia dinh, tac pham Chut tinh phai duoc Dam Vinh Hung mua hop phap cua Truong Tuan Huy the hien qua hop dong cung cac chung tu va su chuyen giao hop phap cua Truong Tuan Huy thi cung co 2 truong hop xay ra.

Truong hop 1: Truong Tuan Huy lam gia Giay xac nhan ban quyen tac gia cua Cuc Ban quyen cap. Truong hop 2: Truong Tuan Huy khang dinh tac pham nay cua minh bang van ban rieng (boi tac gia van co quyen so huu doi voi tac pham du co hay khong dang ky ban quyen tac gia, theo Dieu 6 Luat So huu tri tue).

Ca 2 truong hop neu tren thi Truong Tuan Huy deu sai. Can xac dinh trach nhiem cua Dam Vinh Hung nhu sau:

Thu nhat, quan he giua Truong Nhan va Dam Vinh Hung: Truong Nhan thuc su la tac gia cua ca khuc Chut tinh, duoc the hien qua giay xac nhan ban quyen tac gia nen co quyen so huu ve tai san va duoc quyen tu bao ve khi tac pham bi xam hai. Vi the Truong Nhan duoc quyen kien.

Nguoi bi kien la Dam Vinh Hung, boi Album nay thuoc so huu cua Dam Vinh Hung. Tuy nhien nhu phan tich tren, ca khuc duoc Dam Vinh Hung mua chinh thuc tu Truong Tuan Huy nhung vi Truong Tuan Huy khong phai la chu so huu cua tac pham nen hop dong mua ban nay vo hieu ngay tu luc ky ket.

Theo vu an nay, Dam Vinh Hung da co hanh vi xam pham quyen tac gia tai Dieu 28. Hanh vi xam pham quyen tac gia: Chiem doat quyen tac gia doi voi tac pham van hoc, nghe thuat, khoa hoc; Mao danh tac gia; Cong bo, phan phoi tac pham ma khong duoc phep cua tac gia; Su dung tac pham ma khong duoc phep cua chu so huu quyen tac gia, khong tra tien nhuan but; Xuat ban tac pham ma khong duoc phep cua chu so huu quyen tac gia.

Truong Nhan co quyen kien yeu cau Dam Vinh Hung boi thuong thiet hai do su xam pham ban quyen nay gay ra voi cac yeu cau co ban la cac ton that ve vat chat va tinh than (Dieu 204 Luat So huu Tri tue). Dac biet, trong he thong phap luat nuoc ta thi rieng loai vi pham ban quyen thi chi phi moi luat su cung duoc chap nhan. Nhu vay voi quy dinh cua Luat So huu Tri tue hien hanh, truong hop nay Dam Vinh Hung phai boi thuong theo cac yeu cau cua Truong Nhan.


Dam Vinh Hung bi kien an cap ca khuc
"Theo vu an nay, Dam Vinh Hung da co hanh vi xam pham quyen tac gia tai
Dieu 28, Hanh vi xam pham quyen tac gia"

Ve xu ly vi pham: Vi vu viec da kien ra Toa nen phan quyet cua Toa se gom xu ly vi pham va boi thuong thiet hai. Do dac thu cua hanh vi vi pham quyen tac gia nen ngoai boi thuong thiet hai thi con phai xu ly doi voi tac pham bi vi pham. Truong hop nay vi pham lien quan den ghi sai ten tac gia, ten tac pham nen phai khac phuc bang cach tieu huy hoac dieu chinh sua chua.

Thu hai, quan he giua Dam Vinh Hung va Truong Tuan Huy: Nhu tren da neu, Truong Tuan Huy khong phai la chu so huu cua tac pham nhung van chuyen nhuong san pham cho Dam Vinh Hung la trai phep va vi pham phap luat. Vi su vi pham nay ma Dam Vinh Hung phai boi thuong cho Truong Nhan.

Truong hop nay, Dam Vinh Hung van duoc phap luat bao ve theo nguyen tac "chiem huu bat hop phap ngay tinh", tuc giao dich voi Truong Tuan Huy la vo hieu nhung hoan toan do loi cua Truong Tuan Huy. Nen moi thiet hai cua Dam Vinh Hung thi Truong Tuan Huy phai ganh.

Nhu the, khi giai quyet vu an, Dam Vinh Hung phai yeu cau Toa an dua Truong Tuan Huy vao tu cach to tung la "Nguoi co quyen va nghia vu lien quan" de ganh chiu nghia vu boi thuong thiet hai ma Truong Nhan yeu cau doi voi Dam Vinh Hung. Cung co the, Dam Vinh Hung se khoi kien rieng voi Truong Tuan Huy sau khi da boi thuong cho Truong Nhan.

Hoang Anh (ghi)

Viet Bao

CO THE BAN QUAN TAM

>> Ngo ngang khi Linh Nga khoe anh "tu suong" dep lung linh

>> Kim "sieu vong ba" lan dau "lo dien" sau sinh

>> Phim lot ta suy nghi cua hon 1 ty nguoi dan TQ

>> Yasuy tu choi nhan 10 trieu dong cua khan gia

>> Rosie Huntington tao dang sieu "doc", khoe than nong bong

>> Mai Phuong Thuy len duong tham du Paris Fashion Week

>> 16 chuyen sao “vung trom” rum beng nhat

>>Ngoc Trinh, Thuy Tien cung co luc lo vong 2 ngan mo

>>  Doi dau GHV nhi: Se nhan van hay mua nuoc mat?

>> Can Lo Lo khoe than quen chua "don dep" nach

 

//

Cac bai viet khac:

Tiep theo >>


^ Lên đầu trang ^


Copyright © 2006-2012 by VietBao.vn
Viet Bao Viet Nam - All Rights Reserved.