Hoi thao to chuc khai an den Tran Nong bong nhung tham luan

Thứ ba, 19 Tháng bảy 2011, 12:24 GMT+7

Thuc hu chuyen co nguoi chet trong le phat an 2011?, nguon thu tu le hoi den Tran se di dau?... hang loat nhung cau hoi thang than va nhung tham luan trai chieu nhau khien buoi hoi thao Mo hinh to chuc, quan ly le hoi den Tran Nam Dinh nam 2012 tai TP. Nam Dinh du chi dien ra co 1 ngay nhung da nong bong cho toi luc be mac.

Truoc luong du luan kha lon trong thoi gian gan day ve cach to chuc cung nhu tinh van hoa va lich su co trong le hoi den Tran, nhat la khi chi con nua nam nua la le hoi den Tran 2012 se dien ra, buoi hoi thao da thu hut kha nhieu quan tam cua cac nha khoa hoc, nhung nguoi co trach nhiem quan ly, to chuc, cung nhu su quan tam cua nhieu nguoi dan.
Hoi thao to chuc khai an den Tran: Nong bong nhung tham luan!
Quang canh buoi hoi thao.

Co mat tai buoi hoi thao co rat nhieu cac nha khoa hoc nhu GS.TS Kieu Thu Hoach, TS Nguyen Xuan Nam (nguyen GD So VHTT Nam Dinh), Ong Tran Chien Thang (nguyen Thu truong Bo VH-TT-DL), PGS.TS Dang Van Bai (nguyen Cuc truong Cuc Di San), PGS.TS Truong Quoc Binh (cuu GD Bao tang My thuat), TS Le Thi Minh Ly (Pho Cuc truong Cuc Di san, Bo VHTTDL), PGS. TS Tran Lam Bien, Dai dien Ban lien lac ho Tran Viet Nam va Ban lien lac ho Tran (Nam Dinh,) Chu tich Phuong Loc Vuong, dai dien cua nguoi dan khu vuc den Tran...

Chu toa buoi hoi thao GS. Nguyen Chi Ben khang dinh: "Buoi hoi thao dua tren ket luan cua Bo truong Bo VH-TT-DL Hoang Tuan Anh ve viec Le khai an tai den Tran 2012 phai duoc to chuc dung theo cac nghi thuc truyen thong va se khong to chuc phat an vao dem 14 thang Gieng am lich". Ong nhan manh muc dich cua hoi thao ban ve viec phat an theo hai phuong an ma Bo VH-TT-DL da phe duyet trong de an lan thu 3.

Hai phuong an duoc hoi thao dua ra thao luan do la: 1- Khong to chuc phat An, chi khai An. 2 - van to chuc phat An, nhung phat vao ngay hom sau va keo dai trong 2 hoac 3 ngay sau do.

Hoi thao to chuc khai an den Tran: Nong bong nhung tham luan!

Hoi thao to chuc khai an den Tran: Nong bong nhung tham luan!
Nhung uu diem va han che cua hai phuong an duoc neu ra tai de an.

Nhung thay doi lon nam trong Le hoi den Tran nam nay trong de an cung duoc Bo VH-TT-DL phe duyet ,do la: Khong phan biet sang hen, chuc sac hay dan thuong, than hay so khi den tham du le hoi. Neu to chuc phat an thi khong lay tien, tach bach hai dia diem phat an va cong duc ra hai noi khac nhau. So luong phat an khong han che, keo dai thoi gian phat an, mo dong dia diem phat an

Khong the quan ly le hoi bang thu tuc hanh chinh

Truoc hai phuong an cac nha khoa hoc, cac nha quan ly, va nguoi dan deu da co nhung tham luan soi noi va co nhieu y kien trai chieu nhau nhung tren tinh than xay dung.

"Khong the quan ly le hoi den Tran bang mot thu tuc hanh chinh don gian ma phai qua cong tac nghien cuu khoa hoc mot cach cong khai" - Chu toa hoi thao - GS Nguyen Chi Ben - Vien truong vien VH-NT dua ra y kien.

Nguoi thuyet trinh de an lan thu 3 cua Bo, PGS-TS Luong Ngoc Quang noi: "Day la mot de an chua he co tien le trong qua trinh quan ly van hoa".


Hoi thao to chuc khai an den Tran: Nong bong nhung tham luan!
TS Tran Manh Quang

Chu tich va la dai dien cho hoi dong Tran toc Viet Nam, TS Tran Manh Quang dua ra kien nghi mot cach tha thiet: "Bat cu noi dau co dai le, su nao nhiet va hien tuong xo day la khong tranh khoi, nhung khong vi hien tuong xo day lay an ma mat di truyen thong bao doi nay vao gio Ty ram thang Gieng.

Ong cung nhan manh them rang nam qua viec to chuc va cong tac an ninh trong toan bo le khai An truoc gio phat An da lam tot, tuy nhien sau le khai an, cong tac an ninh da bi noi long khien cong tac to chuc da gap nhieu thieu sot.


Hoi thao to chuc khai an den Tran: Nong bong nhung tham luan!
Ong Tran Quoc Van Ong Tran Quoc Van (80 tuoi) thay mat cac cu bo lao thon Tuc Mac, Phuong Loc Vuong cung co y kien : "Neu khai an xong de den 8h sang ngay Ram thang Gieng chung toi lo lang se phuc tap hon cho nguoi quan ly, lam dao lon le nghi tin nguong truyen thong cua dia phuong. Toi mong muon cac co quan chuc nang quan ly va duy tri tot hon cong tac an ninh tu khi chuan bi phat an den luc phat het an loc". Dac biet ong Quoc Van con kien nghi nen som thu hoi dat cua Cong ty Giong Cay trong rong hang chuc hecta bao quanh khu di tich de mo rong khong gian le hoi.

Dung an cua vua hay an cua dan?

Ve nguon goc lich su cua le khai an Den Tran cac nha khoa hoc phan lon deu khang dinh tai lieu co ve Le khai an thoi Tran chua phat hien duoc (PGS.TS Tran Duc Minh - Chu tich hoi khoa hoc Lich su tinh Nam Dinh), tuy nhien nhieu nha khoa hoc da nhat tri rang le hoi den Tran hinh thanh tu lau doi trong dan gian va tro thanh net van hoa dep.

Theo GS.TS Kieu Thu Hoach - Nghien cuu vien cao cap Vien Nghien cuu Van hoa dan gian "Khai an theo dung nghia la mot thu tuc hanh chinh, nhung dung trong le hoi van hoa tai Den Tran thi mang khai niem dan gian chu khong phai la mot thu tuc hanh chinh nen le hoi Den Tran chi mang tinh chat cua le hoi van hoa dan gian don thuan".

TS Nguyen Hong Kien - Vien Khao co hoc Viet Nam - nguoi con dat Thanh Nam cung dua ra y kien ve nguon goc lich su cua le hoi den Tran: "Khong he co chuyen nguon goc cua le khai an bat nguon tu viec sau khi danh thang quan Nguyen - Mong, vua Tran thiet trieu o Tuc Mac - Thien Truong de thuong cong, ban tuoc nhu nhieu nguoi, nhieu bao noi/viet. Tuong truyen sau khi chien thang quan Nguyen lan thu nhat, vao ngay 14 thang Gieng, vua Tran da mo tiec chieu dai tai phu Thien Truong va phong chuc cho cac quan, quan co cong chu khong he co chuyen phat an hay khai an. Vi vay le hoi khai an den Tran chi la le hoi co nguon goc dan gian dac trung tai Nam Dinh ma thoi".


Ve chiec an dung trong le hoi Den Tran cac nha khoa hoc tai buoi hoi thao cung lam ro nguon goc cua chiec an, va dung chiec An nao khi hien nay da phat hien ra nhieu chiec An khac.

TS. Tran Chien Thang - nguyen Thu truong Bo VH-TT-DL noi : Chiec an dang dung trong le hoi Den Tran la "Tran Mieu Tu Dien" cua dan gian tao ra nen co the dung de in an va phat cho dan. Hien nay uat hien mot chiec an khac nhieu nguoi tranh luan do la an "Tran Trieu Chi Bao" - day la an cua vua vi vay chi co vua moi duoc dung de in va phat an. Viec tranh cai dung chiec an "Tran Trieu Chi Bao" la khong phu hop.


Hoi thao to chuc khai an den Tran: Nong bong nhung tham luan!
T.S Nguyen Xuan Dien. TS. Nguyen Xuan Dien - Pho GD Vien nghien cuu Han Nom lam ro hon ve nguon goc cua chiec an "Tran Mieu Tu Dien" "Toi khang dinh chiec an nay la cua dan gian boi khong bao gio nguoi ta lam chiec an ma chu chan vuong chan chan nhu the ca ma phai la chu dai trien, tieu trien hoac chu le... con chu Tran Mieu Tu Dien chan phuong cua chiec an Tran hien nay nguoi xua khong ai lam the ca!".

Xin an de len chuc - chuyen hao huyen
Ve y nghia cua le hoi den Tran - dac biet la la an theo nhu nhieu nguoi don thoi la dem lai tai loc, thang quan tien chuc... tat ca da bi phu dinh hoan toan ngay tai buoi hoi thao. Cac nha khoa hoc chi dong y voi quan diem viec co duoc mot chiec an chi la co y nghia cau suc khoe, cau may man binh an va chi la tinh chat tam ly.
Hoi thao to chuc khai an den Tran: Nong bong nhung tham luan!
TS. Tran Chien Thang - nguyen thu truong Bo VH-TT-DL

TS. Tran Chien Thang - nguyen thu truong Bo VH-TT-DL thang than trong hoi thao: "Toi ban than 10 nam duong chuc deu co an mot la do nguoi than tang hai la da tu tay lay an nhung khong he thay minh duoc thang tien trong chuc vu. Va toi cung thay nhieu nguoi khac co duoc an cung bi mat hoac xuong chuc vu. Vi vay moi don dai ve la an toi khang dinh deu la khong co that!".

TS Nguyen Xuan Dien bay to quan diem: "Le hoi cua dan gian chung ta phai tra ve cho dan gian, tra ve cho cong dong. Chung ta dung khong ho hoan hay lam qua len y nghia cua no. Le hoi phai co tu tuong va tinh than va o le hoi den Tran la tinh than cua hao khi Dong A tuc la quan dan mot long, do la gac thu nha doan ket de lo viec nuoc. Do moi la su tiep noi tinh than cua cac vua Tran".


Hoi thao to chuc khai an den Tran: Nong bong nhung tham luan!
Hoi thao to chuc khai an den Tran: Nong bong nhung tham luan!
Ket qua khao sat tham do y kien nguoi dan ve tac dung cua an den Tran.

GS.TS Tran Lam Bien nhan manh: "Cai ket cua le hoi la de quy tu long doan ket va yeu nuoc cua nhan dan!".


Nhung tham luan day tam huyet mang tinh xay dung cua cac nha khoa hoc trong hoi thao se duoc cac cap co tham quyen xem xet va phe duyet vao thang 8/2011.


Tra loi ve thong tin co mot nguoi chet trong le hoi Khai an Den Tran nam 2011, Chu tich UBND xa Loc Vuong noi chuyen ngat, mat trom mat cap la co nhung chuyen nguoi chet la khong co. Pho Chu tich UBND TP Nam Dinh cung khang dinh khong co ai chet trong qua trinh tham gia le hoi.

Ve nguon thu cua le hoi den Tran: Truoc nam 2007 nguon thu la dia phuong thu. Sau 2007, Thanh pho Nam Dinh quan ly ve mat nha nuoc, con thu la UBND phuong thu. So tien thu duoc 60% ti le tien cong duc la dia phuong thua. 40% la danh cho ban quan ly di tich danh cho viec tu bo, ton tao xay dung di tich.
Bai va anh: Nguyen Hoang

Cac bai viet khac:

Tiep theo >>


^ Lên đầu trang ^


Copyright © 2006-2012 by VietBao.vn
Viet Bao Viet Nam - All Rights Reserved.